Astrix Security vs Clutch Security
Side-by-side comparison of identity tools. Sponsored placement is disclosed where applicable.
Quick answer
Astrix Security vs Clutch Security: which should you choose?
Short answer
Astrix Security vs Clutch Security have overlapping use cases in identity and access management. The right pick depends on your company size, deployment model, integrations, and pricing tolerance — compare those attributes side-by-side below.
- Best for
- Astrix Security: Enterprise security teams — particularly existing Cisco security customers — who want NHI and AI agent identity controls that will live inside Cisco Identity Intelligence, Duo, and Secure Access. · Clutch Security: Identity security and IAM teams at mid-market to enterprise organizations that need visibility and governance over sprawling machine identities, secrets, and emerging AI agents.
- When to choose
- Pick the option whose company-size fit, deployment model, and integrations most closely match your stack.
- When not to choose
- Skip a head-to-head if you haven't shortlisted a category yet — start with the IAM Stack Finder instead.
- Related tools & categories
- Astrix SecurityClutch SecurityIAM Stack FinderBuyer resources
| Attribute | ||
|---|---|---|
| Best for | Enterprise security teams — particularly existing Cisco security customers — who want NHI and AI agent identity controls that will live inside Cisco Identity Intelligence, Duo, and Secure Access. | Identity security and IAM teams at mid-market to enterprise organizations that need visibility and governance over sprawling machine identities, secrets, and emerging AI agents. |
| Short description | Astrix Security discovers and secures non-human identities, AI agents, and MCP servers, and provisions secure-by-design agents through its Agent Control Plane with short-lived credentials and just-in-time access. Following its acquisition by Cisco, its capabilities are being integrated into Cisco's identity and zero-trust portfolio. | Clutch Security is a non-human identity (NHI) security platform that maps service accounts, keys, tokens, and AI agents to their origins via its Identity Lineage graph, then layers on lifecycle management, posture, and threat detection. It added an Agentic AI Governance module for discovering and setting guardrails around AI agents and their credential usage. |
| Company size | Mid-market, Enterprise | Mid-market, Enterprise |
| Deployment | SaaS / Cloud-hosted | SaaS / Cloud-hosted |
| Source | Proprietary | Proprietary |
| Pricing model | Contact vendor for pricing | Contact vendor for pricing |
| Integrations | AWS, GCP, Azure, Kubernetes, Okta, GitHub, Snowflake, Salesforce | AWS, GCP, Azure, Kubernetes, Okta, Microsoft Entra ID, GitHub, Terraform |
| Categories | SaaS Access Governance, Machine Identity, Non-Human Identity, AI Agent Identity | Secrets / API Key Management, Non-Human Identity, AI Agent Identity |
| Claimed profile |
Buyer help
Request a vendor shortlist
Tell us what you're evaluating and IDSync will identify the identity, access, and security tools that fit your use case.
Request a vendor shortlist
Tell us your stack and we'll send a tailored shortlist.
Run the IAM Stack Finder
Get a guided shortlist in under 3 minutes.
Buyer's guides & checklists
RFP templates, migration checklists, and rollout playbooks.